# The insurer denied or reduced the benefit: what you can do

Published: 23 October 2026 · Updated: 23 October 2026

The neighbour above you left the washing machine running, and the water destroyed your ceiling and kitchen. You reported the loss, sent photos and invoices, and after a few weeks a letter arrives: we are reducing the insurance benefit by 40%, or rejecting it outright. When an insurance company has denied the insurance benefit or reduced it, that need not be the final word. The law gives it only certain grounds, and you have the right to know which of them it used.

## The insurance company must give reasons for its decision

After the loss is reported, the insurance company opens an investigation and must tell you its result.

> „Šetření je skončeno sdělením jeho výsledků osobě, která uplatnila právo na pojistné plnění; pojistitel této osobě v textové podobě zdůvodní výši pojistného plnění, popřípadě důvod jeho zamítnutí.“
>
> *Section 2797(1) of Act No. 89/2012 Coll., the Civil Code*

In plain terms: the insurance company must explain to you in writing, for example by email, why it is paying you exactly that amount, or why it will pay nothing. A general sentence "we do not recognise the claim" is not enough. If the explanation is missing or you do not understand it, write and ask for it.

## How long it may investigate the loss

The insurance benefit is payable within 15 days of the end of the investigation, unless the contract provides otherwise (Section 2798(1) of the Civil Code). If the insurance company does not finish the investigation within three months of the report, it must tell you in writing why it cannot be closed. On your request, it is also to provide you with an appropriate advance, unless it has a reasonable ground to refuse it (Section 2798(2) of the Civil Code). If it breaches this duty for reasons on its side, it is in default (Section 2798(3)).

## When the insurance company may reduce or refuse the benefit

**Untrue answers when taking out the insurance.** If you answered the insurance company’s questions untruthfully when entering into the contract and because of that paid a lower premium, the insurance company may reduce the benefit in the ratio of the premium paid to the premium it should have received (Section 2800(1) of the Civil Code). It may refuse the benefit entirely only if it learned of the fact that caused the loss only after the loss, it could not discover that fact because of your culpable breach of a duty, and, had it known of that fact, it would not have entered into the contract or would have entered into it on different terms (Section 2809 of the Civil Code).

**A breach of duty that affected the loss.** If you breached a duty and that had a substantial effect on the occurrence of the loss, its extent, or on determining the amount of the benefit, the insurance company may reduce the benefit, but only in proportion to the effect that breach had (Section 2800(2) of the Civil Code). The reduction must therefore correspond to what you influenced by your conduct, not to the whole loss.

**Underinsurance.** This mainly concerns household insurance and real-estate insurance. If the sum insured in the contract is lower than what the property is actually worth at the time of the loss, the insurance company reduces the benefit in the same proportion (Section 2854 of the Civil Code). Example: the household is worth CZK 1,000,000, but it is insured for CZK 500,000. Of a loss of CZK 100,000 you then receive CZK 50,000. This does not apply if you agreed in the contract that the benefit will not be reduced because of underinsurance.

**Exclusions and limits in the insurance terms.** Many disputes arise from what the contract does not cover at all, or from limits and the deductible. Read the terms, therefore, and check whether the insurance company relies on a specific clause and whether it really fits your case.

## How to challenge the decision

1. **Read the reasons and the terms.** Find out which provision of the law or of the insurance terms the insurance company relies on. For underinsurance, recalculate the property value it used.
2. **Send the insurance company a written objection.** Write what you disagree with and why, how much you claim, and which documents you enclose: photos, invoices, a repair estimate, or your own expert report. Give it an appropriate time to reply.
3. **Turn to out-of-court resolution.** For non-life insurance, that is, for example, household, real-estate, motor hull or travel insurance, you can file a proposal with the Office of the Ombudsman of the Czech Insurance Association (Kancelář ombudsmana České asociace pojišťoven). The Ministry of Industry and Trade (Ministerstvo průmyslu a obchodu) has authorised it to resolve consumer disputes, the proceedings are free of charge and are to end within 90 days. File the proposal no later than one year from the moment you first asserted the claim with the insurance company (Section 20p of the Consumer Protection Act). The ombudsman does not deal with claims that you assert as the injured party under someone else’s liability insurance, for example under the insurance of the neighbour who flooded you, or under the compulsory motor third-party liability insurance of the person at fault for the accident. It will help you in a dispute with your own insurance company. Disputes arising from life insurance are decided by the Financial Arbitrator (finanční arbitr) (Section 1(1)(e) of Act No. 229/2002 Sb., on the Financial Arbitrator).
4. **Watch the limitation period.** For the right to the insurance benefit, the general three-year limitation period starts to run only one year after the insured event (Section 626 and Section 629(1) of the Civil Code). For life insurance, the right to the benefit is time-barred after ten years (Section 635(1)).

## What to do next

The insurance company denied or reduced the benefit and you disagree with its reasons? Describe to Legamik what happened and how the insurance company decided. Legamik will prepare an objection citing the specific provisions, quantify the amount you want paid in addition, and keep track of the deadline for a reply. You then send the letter yourself.

---

*Legamik is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. For complex disputes, we recommend consulting an attorney.*

Source: https://legamik.com/cz/en/blog/insurer-denied-or-reduced-claim
