← Back to the blog
Guide26 October 20264 min read

Contractual penalty and fees hidden in the terms and conditions

You cancelled an order the day after paying, and the online shop refunded you a thousand crowns less, supposedly because of a "cancellation fee under Article 12 of the terms and conditions". Or, after a subscription ended, you received an invoice for a contractual penalty you had never heard of. Few people read the terms and conditions, and businesses know it. The law takes this into account, so a contractual penalty in the terms and conditions, or a fee hidden on the tenth page, does not have to be valid merely because you clicked to agree when ordering.

What overrides the terms and conditions

The terms and conditions are part of the contract, only drawn up separately. What you agree with the seller differently in the contract takes precedence over the wording of the terms (Section 1751(1) of the Civil Code). Keep every written reply in which the business confirmed something to you before the order.

If a sentence in the terms or in the contract can be read in two ways, the interpretation most favourable to you as a consumer applies (Section 1812(1) of the Civil Code). An unclearly worded fee is therefore borne by the business, not by you.

A clause you could not have expected

A special section covers rules that do not ordinarily appear in the terms.

In plain terms: if a seller hides in the terms a rule that a reasonable customer would not have expected, and you did not expressly agree to it, it has no effect. The content of the provision is assessed, and so is the way it is written. A rule hidden in small print in the middle of a long article works rather in your favour. An example may be a condition under which the online shop may unilaterally raise the price of the order after payment, or a fee for the "administrative processing" of every returned parcel that was nowhere mentioned when you ordered.

Clauses that are disregarded for consumers

A business cannot use the terms to get around part of the consumer-protection rules. A clause that departs from them to your disadvantage is treated as if it were not in the contract (Section 1812(2)). The sentence "goods from a sale cannot be returned" therefore does not take away your right to withdraw within 14 days from a contract concluded on an online shop. You send the withdrawal yourself.

The Civil Code also lists clauses that are always unfair in consumer contracts (Section 1814(1)). They include, for example, those that

  • limit your rights arising from defective performance, for example "we accept complaints only in the original packaging",
  • allow the business, of its own will, to change your rights or obligations,
  • bind you to performance on terms you could not have acquainted yourself with before the contract was concluded,
  • impose a disproportionate sanction on you for a breach of an obligation.

An unfair clause is disregarded unless the consumer invokes it (Section 1815 of the Civil Code). In practice that means it does not apply to you, but if in some exceptional case it helped you, you may rely on it.

Contractual penalty: when it is a problem

A business may claim a contractual penalty only if you agreed to it, in a fixed amount or with a method for determining the amount (Section 2048(1) of the Civil Code). If the penalty was not written anywhere in the contract or in the terms, there is nothing to derive it from.

For penalties hidden only in the terms and conditions, the courts long considered whether they may be there at all. In 2013 the Constitutional Court (Ústavní soud) (nález sp. zn. I. ÚS 3512/11) concluded that, for consumers, the penalty belongs in the contract itself, not in the terms the contract merely refers to. The Supreme Court (Nejvyšší soud) clarified this in 2018 (judgment file no. 33 ICdo 45/2017 of 28 March 2018, still under the former Civil Code): placement in the terms alone does not automatically make the penalty invalid. It is assessed mainly whether the penalty is proportionate, and as part of that, whether you could actually read and understand it before signing.

When the penalty clearly does not correspond to what you breached, you can object that it is a disproportionate sanction under Section 1814(1)(l) of the Civil Code. An excessively high penalty may also be reduced by a court on application (Section 2051 of the Civil Code).

How to proceed

  1. Ask for the specific provision. Ask the business to write which article of the terms it relies on and in what wording it applied on the day of your order or signature.
  2. Find what you saw. Go through the confirmation email and the terms the seller attached to it. You are looking for whether anyone specifically drew your attention to the fee or the penalty.
  3. Object in writing. Write why you disagree with the fee or the penalty, and state which provision of the law you rely on. If the amount has already been deducted, ask for it to be returned and give the business a reasonable time limit.
  4. If the business does not respond. You can submit the dispute for out-of-court resolution: for operators, to the Czech Telecommunication Office (Český telekomunikační úřad), for energy, to the Energy Regulatory Office (Energetický regulační úřad), and for other shops, to the Czech Trade Inspection Authority (Česká obchodní inspekce) (Section 20e of the Consumer Protection Act).

What to do next

Is the business charging you a fee or a penalty you did not know about? Describe to Legamik what happened and which provision the business relies on. Legamik will prepare a letter in which you object to the fee with citations of specific provisions, and will watch the deadline for a reply. You then send the letter yourself.


Legamik is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. In the case of complex disputes we recommend consulting an attorney.

Your rights will not wait.

Describe your problem and find out for free how strong your case is. The finished letter costs 249 CZK and you pay only when you actually want it.

Fixed price, no subscription